From Trinity News (print and online): http://trinitynews.ie/back-to-our-futures/
Martin O’Donnell examines what drives people’s decisions around the CAO, why high-point achievers are edged towards medicine and why we need to rethink our current paradigms
Suppressing sixth year
The Leaving Cert holds a special place in Ireland – the media has a morbid fascination with it which it expresses in supplement after supplement in newspapers and with story after story on radio and television. This doesn’t really help my personal attempts to suppress my own Leaving Cert. years; years filled with mindless study, unrelenting anxiety and total lack of a social life. It becomes easier with time and I had avoided thinking of the era for quite some time until I discussed the CAO with my cousin at Christmas (although, I reserved recanting my own experience for obvious reasons).
At the time, the CAO seemed secondary to actual Leaving Cert. and if I’m being honest – amid the stress, it was an after-thought. I had a rough idea of what I was going to put down – not the exact order, but I had the ‘gist’ of a significant life decision. Each student in my school had one meeting with the school guidance counsellor in order to talk through their CAO choices before the February deadline. As he slowly went through the class, it seemed like he was taking roughly 20-35 minutes with each student. One morning I was dutifully called and entered the room expecting to miss a class – although in my case, the meeting lasted only a mere 10 minutes. I rattled off my CAO choices which he wrote down, he noted I had a good chance of pulling off my first choice based on my Christmas exams and then he asked me was I happy with my choices and my backups and well…that was it.
The brevity of our meeting is something that always puzzles me as it was the only meeting I had with a guidance counsellor during sixth year. Surely a life decision of such gravity required more than 10 minutes? Maybe he was in a hurry? Maybe my ‘cool exterior’ fooled him into thinking I was certain of my choices and he believed I could achieve them based on previous results? Frankly, however, I suspect one of the main reasons for his brevity was that he actually approved of my choice – Medicine.
What’s a 625 pointer to do?
Medicine as a course perfectly embodies many of the things society views as important – it has a ‘noble’ career with a defined path towards secure employment that leads to good pay and a comfortable life. This was how it was sold by my parents, my teachers and my guidance counsellor and genuinely none of this is totally untrue and probably is the main reason it has always been one of the highest points courses in the country. However, this pitch omits some of the significant drawbacks of medicine – it takes several years of gruelling study followed by many years of long-hours and training before these ideals come to be realised, if they in fact ever do. Similar values and worth are ascribed to other health science courses and professions such as law. The conventional wisdom is that if you can do one of these courses or even have a chance of doing them you should.
Adjusting our approach
This decision is massive one for an individual to make at any point because for many, their choice on their CAO will play a large role in their later life. Blindly pushing anyone who gets 625 to do medicine is clearly absurd regardless of the motivations – just because a person can do it doesn’t mean they should. This sort of ‘snobbery’ surrounding medicine, which seems pervasive and undoubtedly drives some students to do the course, should really be abandoned. Instead, when choosing a course, students need to make informed choices. This doesn’t just apply to so-called ‘high achievers’, but to all students. In some schools, this may already be the case, but it is by no means a universal approach in Ireland.
Less emphasis needs to be placed on societal validation and instead, I feel students should be encouraged to critically think about what they want in life. What are you passionate about? What do you want to explore more? What is important to you? If a person is passionate about business, well then I hope they find their niche and are successful; if a person dreams of becoming a scientist to cure disease, I hope they find the next penicillin; and if a person longs to compose poetry, I hope they are the next Kavanagh or Plath. In the end, it may be that what is important to an individual overlap with reasons society and our parents believe are important, but students need to come to the decision of their own volition.
Importantly, if someone is passionate and interested in something that doesn’t require a college degree, or even a Leaving Cert. for that matter, they should be encouraged to push forward with their aspirations. I vividly remember a classmate in secondary school being told by a teacher to do a college degree instead of an apprenticeship, in spite of the fact he had no interest in college whatsoever – this advice serves nobody except schools looking to up their rankings in league tables. Similarly, others were told to avoid certain courses because ‘there are not too many jobs in that area’ – while admittedly future careers have to be taken into account, they should not be the ‘be-all and end-all’ – satisfaction with studies surely deserves a high place in consideration too.
Some argue that the blame for a lack of critical thinking is down to age – that 17/18 year olds are not ready to make such a major decision; and that people should pick a broad course first before deciding in later years to sub-specialise. However, this is simply kicking the can down the road – many students do know what they want to do in the Leaving Cert. year and forcing them to wait is unfair. For those who do not or are uncertain, they should not be encouraged to pursue something blindly. A cultural shift is required and the idea of a ‘gap year’ after the Leaving Cert. perhaps needs to be encouraged more. This is not to say that certain courses have become too sub-specialised, but a moderate approach is required – we do not need to make courses too broad either.
The big question
As for myself, I did not end up altering my CAO courses between February and the end of the year – so the ‘gist’ of a life decision became the actual decision. At the time, I rationalised that I liked medicine because I thought it would be stimulating and I thought I would enjoy interacting with people on a day-to-day basis. The problem is nearly any course fits that description and I was quite interested in politics, maths and Irish at the time. I think it would be naïve of me to think that I didn’t think of my parents’ and teachers’ approval in coming to my decision.
Yet, when asked by my cousin what I thought of medicine, the answer was simple – I really enjoy it and have since found many reasons to love the course, but I admitted I was lucky. Ultimately, I asked him – What do you want in life? – It’s a big question, perhaps one that many of us still can’t answer, but considering the enormity of the decision it is probably warranted. I wasn’t really expecting an answer on the spot.